Recently, I decided that I needed to update my life insurance portfolio. With a range of life events taking place, and a 10 year term policy purchased in 2004 coming to a natural end, I was poised to take quick action. Suffering from mild OCD, I actually started the process a full 8 weeks before the anniversary date. Little did I know that I was dancing on a razor’s edge in terms of timing. This sort of “secret shopper” experience has been frustrating, humorous and thought provoking all at the same time. Does it really need to be this hard? If a process is only as good as its weakest link, this one sets a new standard on the low side of the scale.
In an era of instant access, and nearly instantaneous gratification, I went online to start shopping at an aggregator site. To my surprise, this was less functional than the site I recalled from 10 years ago but it did earn me a call back from a call center agent. After going through the medical questions, we landed on the need to “draw fluids”, a process that could take 2-3 weeks to complete. Given the green light, this process started. It took 3-4 weeks to actually schedule the blood draw.
Thinking the process had run amuck, I went to a second carrier directly. After completing their app online, I was called back in minutes for the medical questions. Because of how I answered one question, I was cautioned that I wouldn’t qualify for the super preferred rate and that the agent had no idea what the premium might be. The thrust of the conversation was that it would likely be around 50% more, but that this was just a SWAG. Clearly surprised that I wanted to proceed anyway (not a great trait in sales) we again marched into the need to draw fluids. A process that could take, I was assured, 2-3 weeks.
The third carrier was a traditional Agency company that I decided to test to see if the web site channel worked. Although it took several business days for someone to respond, when they did, the agent was effective and knowledgeable. She was able to share different premium scenarios and suggest which products might best fit the need. While the low end price was higher than the direct company super-preferred rate, the “likely” rate based on the medical questions was lower. And, of course, drawing blood would take several weeks.
Several interesting points in the process:
Across the board, the process seems broken … or at least archaic. I became a little worried about coverage gaps with the ’04 policy exporting, but I shouldn’t have been concerned. The old carrier indicated that it takes a calendar quarter to actually lapse the contract … whose premium would triple on the next anniversary barring action on my part.
At a time when the balance of consumer’s financial lives is so readily available through self service and guided experience, this seems like a trip back in time to a different world. Actions are measured in weeks and quarters rather than minutes and hours. Rather than full transparency on information and pricing, the process feels both secretive and ill-informed.
The process also seems to be intentionally inefficient. When my doctor did his version of the fluid analysis, we had results in 2-3 days. The paramedic firm used by all three carriers said it took 2-3 weeks. How could that possibly be?
Left to a natural course, this process could run (in total) 6-10 weeks, by my estimation. At that point, I will be presented with “take it or leave it” offers from all the carriers involved. I will, of course, have a personal choice to make at that point, armed with full disclosure and valid pricing as inputs. In the end, it will have a happy outcome for some.
This got me thinking about my own children and their Gen Y peers. They would be highly unlikely to participate in an exercise as slow and as painful as this one. Baby Boomers like me may now be closing in on purchasing their last life insurance contracts as other life events loom.
For carriers, the time to think about the required paradigm shifts is coming quickly. Those footsteps you hear are future generations of prospects but they may be running away, rather than toward, you!
Big data, mobile capabilities, access to a form of Telematics and other devices may all prove to be game changers sooner than we think. Remember what life was like before SmartPhone? I don’t either…